.It's deja vu all over once again for the Bulldogs, slammed straight out of the finals along with Luke Beveridge's dubious transfer the spotlight.Plus Geelong's fix on the run, where the Heeney Robbery places enduring, Brisbane's clear problem and also the much-needed primary award change.The big problems from week some of the 2024 AFL finals analyzed in Chatting Points!Watch the most effective coverage of the 2024 AFL finals, along with expert evaluation as well as every video game till the Grand Final deal with no ad-breaks during the course of play, on Kayo. New to Kayo? Start your totally free test today > Finals Week 1IMAGINE WHAT YOU COULD BE PURCHASING INSTEAD. For Free as well as confidential help call 1800u00a0858u00a0858 or even see gamblinghelponline.org.au.The Week 1 finals AFL Talking Points are in.Source: FOX SPORTSOOPS, BEVO DID IT AGAINNext year, the Western Bulldogs need to just attack mimic, as well as skip everything up until the ultimate round. Because they simply always keep carrying out the same points once more and also again.For the 3rd year in a row their finals future dropped to the ultimate day for the 5th time since the 2016 banner, they discovered themselves in an elimination final.And the feast-or-famine nature of their Septembers continued as, for the 4th opportunity, they were actually knocked out of the finals without a win.But the deja vu doesn't stop there certainly because once again the Bulldogs' season finishes along with Luke Beveridge's decision-making arriving under fire.They were competitive early versus Hawthorn however factors promptly fell apart on Friday night and you have to ponder the amount of of the loss began Thursday night, when the picked team was actually exposed. Given that the tinkerer went to it again.Mitchell handles Ginni's bar tricks|01:44 The positional complications began in protection, as they typically have for the Bulldogs in recent times. Rory Lobb's increase right into an amazingly good trick guardian continued yet he only didn't possess sufficient aid Liam Jones restricted Port Gunston yet didn't do a lot in other places, while James O'Donnell was actually well defeated through Calsher Dear.The pair of are similarly unskilled therefore on its own that is actually not a large shock however it is actually still rather ludicrous that the 56th choice in the best recent nationwide receipt had the capacity to dominate the Pet dogs aerially like he did.But it had not been only the protection, due to the fact that any type of back six would certainly've strained when having to speak up for 59 inside 50s - the much bigger issue was the Canines producing simply 39 inside 50s of their own.Harvey Gallagher devoted loads of time on an airfoil, rather than Lachie McNeil that continued, and also neither man had an effect while Lachie Shrub summarized one of the Bulldogs' huge list concerns - along with the previously delisted Hawk needed as being one of their primary representatives off halfback.Bramble only isn't pretty strong sufficient because function the lack of prime Caleb Daniel, who has fallen off sufficient defensively that he can not be actually soft-pedaled back, has been notable.Throw in the puzzling non-selection of Rhylee West, who will possess probably made an effort to confine James Sicily in the Pets' ahead 50, along with James Harmes chose but doing little bit of - and also the bits-and-pieces players just appeared to be in the wrong places.High flighting Hawks knock out Bulldogs|02:26 And afterwards there's the Bont.Beveridge ignited in his post-match interview when the contributions of arguably the AFL's finest player were questioned." Possess you received simple facts about that (his pause the ground)? He may possess received stuck on (the seat) momentarily or two longer (than planned), but he was actually okay," the instructor said." He tried to raise our company in the final one-fourth, he booted a target, he just about booted a 2nd (a try touched through ally Aaron Naughton near the line), and also was the information at three-quarter time." Whether he was actually lugging a trauma or not, Marcus Bontempelli had no place near sufficient influence for the Bulldogs to have a chance on Friday evening, and also the actual concern is why he had not been in the midfield through the center of the video game - particularly if he was actually fit.Despite Beveridge's demonstrations, Bontempelli spent 22% of the 2nd and 3rd fourths blended off the ground, and also while on the ground had only 4 fingertips, no allowances as well as no score participations, devoting virtually the whole entire period up forward.Once Bontempelli entered into the middle very early in the 4th one-fourth, he resembled himself once again. However it was insufficient, too late." Zero effect in a competitive final. The most effective player, the All-Australian leader, is actually either unemployed or even onward," as Kane Cornes placed it on 9's Sunday Footy Show.None of these positional telephone calls, on their own, are actually why the Bulldogs dropped. The Hawks also participated in really damn effectively, with their tension causing the Canines' change game to fall apart.But they all lead to a constant trend of Beveridge tinkering his way to both excellence and also failing. He does not possess the most effective listing in the AFL, like some experts say, considering that the personnel down back as well as perhaps partially of the midfield stay an issue.Dejected Bevo information what failed|09:39 Yet their absolute best is actually clearly adequate. As constantly occurs with the Canines, they played dazzling footy sometimes throughout the home as well as away period but were not constant enough to earn the dual chance. (They have actually still never finished in the top 4 under Beveridge.) Thus when they experienced a red-hot Hawthorn, one poor evening was enough to finish their season. It's a bit of a shame, given that this staff was most definitely satisfactory over the rear half of the year to succeed a number of finals (and also perhaps even the significant one), but they fell small in their one chance - so they may just blame themselves.They are actually as well great, and also Beveridge has been as well productive over his job, to force an adjustment on top. But they are actually just about trapped within this loophole of good-but-not-good-enough, and if it is actually tremendously aggravating for observers, it must be actually also much worse for the Bulldogs faithful.WHAT'S brand-new PUSSYCATS?Geelong's potential to stay on top of the AFL mountain for as long is actually absolutely remarkable.When you think about one of the most productive staffs in recent times, Geelong's account is much more impressive.Hawthorn most certainly possessed a golden era in the very early 2010s, yet victory over the Bulldogs on Friday evening was their initial finals gain in 9 years.Richmond gained three banners in four periods and now looked fated to stay in the blues of the AFL ladder for a number of years with a mass player exodus looming.On the different palm, Geelong has actually lost out on September activity simply twice over the last 18 periods. That is fabulous consistency in a competition that is essentially developed to make an effort as well as make every effort in the direction of equality.One of the major factors behind their astounding results over the last two decades is their potential to find a rough diamond when it concerns the draft.Scott opens up on collection gamble|09:03 Geelong have scooped up pair of downright stars coming from the draft lately, in Lawson Humphries and also Shaun Mannagh.Externally in the course of in 2015's trade time frame, questions were actually asked about why the Cats were being thus enduring in seeking a late selection back in profit in the Esava Ratugolea business. Why were they being actually thus determined regarding acquiring one more pick back that they could certainly not even use happened draft night?The Felines picked Humphries, a pretty unfamiliar Swan Districts item, with the 2nd final selection of in 2013's draft-- select 63. Humphries has actually starred in his handful of video games at the top level, showcasing dazzling calmness and also ball make use of all over the half-back line.The 182cm child is an awesome decision-maker as well as has actually turned into one of Chris Scott's 'go-to men' visiting of protection. On Thursday evening he was among Geelong's best, scoring twenty fingertips as well as 486 metres gained.Then there is actually Shaun Mannagh, the mature-aged VFL superstar that has actually become a nail down the most ideal 23 in the 2nd half of the year. Mannagh put his name up in lights in the 2023 VFL marvelous ultimate, where he booted 6 majors and acquired 28 disposals. The 27-year-old was rewarded with an AFL agreement in last year's draught, taken with selection 36, and hasn't he paid off the faith?Mannagh was one of his side's ideal against the Electrical power in the certifying final, videotaping 23 fingertips and also 3.1. The former Werribee item positions elite for fingertips and handles this season and also has actually averaged 1.3 objectives per activity as a medium-forward. Increasing Star Ollie Dempsey has likewise started in leaps and also bounds this season to turn into one of the absolute most necessary players to a side ready to embark on yet another initial final.Not just have the Cats had the capacity to find results at the draft, yet their one-of-a-kind employment technique has actually also seen them become a location club for adversary players too.The Cats offered the ranch for ex-Giant Jeremy Cameron as well as the way of life additionally interested right now captain Patrick Dangerfield. Include the likes of Port Bowes, Tanner Bruhn, Tyson Stengle and Oliver Henry, the Kitties have had easy selling on their own as a home for location players.But it's not as though the Cats have not transformed. Nine gamers that included in Thursday night's certifying last success carried out certainly not play in the 2022 premiership, merely 2 years ago.ABC's Kyle Pollard mentioned on X that that is not diverse to Richmond immediately." For circumstance, Richmond's final around crew this year possessed 11 that didn't play in their premierships," he claimed." That is actually certainly not a take on the Tigers, it is actually only a fabulous 24 months of restoration from Geelong." While Chris Scott as well as the on-field celebrities obtain a lot of honors as well as rightly therefore, the job of Stephen Wells, Andrew Mackie and the recruiting crew is incomparable in this competition.Geelong control poor Port Adelaide|03:02 HEENEY PARTICIPATES IN THE SCG'S AMAZING MOUNT RUSHMOREIt might certainly not be the home of footy, yet the SCG is actually the home of everlasting finals moments.Sydney's Isaac Heeney-led comeback on Saturday afternoon joins the pantheon of astonishing September action to have actually occurred at the well known venue.Former Footscray and also Sydney gamer transformed journalist Neil Cordy quipped it will be actually known as 'Heeney's Break-in' after the celebrity's 30-disposal, three-goal game.But the fourth finals edition of the Sydney Derby might certainly not have actually also been actually the best comeback by the Swans in an SCG final.Swans COMEBACK coming from 27-point deficit|03:29 Besides the 2005 flag wouldn't have been actually achievable if Nick Davis had not possessed an other-worldly 4th quarter in the semi-final, kicking four of Sydney's 7 objectives on the night in the space of 21 moments to stun Geelong.Don' t fail to remember the 1996 preparatory ultimate, when any sort of rating would certainly do for Tony Lockett, and Plugger's factor placed the Swans right into the flag decider.And heck, Sunday's training final may not have been actually the very best last at the SCG this years! Always remember Collingwood's near-comeback in the 2022 prelim, when the Swans led by 6 targets early in the 3rd fourth, and also by 21 aspects with 22 minutes used the fourth?The concerns were actually high with all four activities but the nature of Sydney's comeback on Saturday, against their arch-rivals as well as with some ridiculous private initiatives, could create it No. 1. And also the best part? It implies we are actually obtaining one more video game at the SCG in two weeks' time, when the Swans multitude either Port Adelaide or even Hawthorn in a prelim.Swans-Port is actually fascinating after the means the Power demolished them a handful of full weeks back Swans-Hawks is actually even better, provided exactly how much Sam Mitchell's men have arrived considering that being bashed by John Longmire's edge to fall to 1-6 on the season.Let's simply wish it is actually yet another close one." ULTIMATE USE" Heeney Hanger quits SCG|00:30' FRETTING INDICATIONS' COUGARS NEED TO ADDRESSBrisbane might have put Carlton to the saber with a first one-half demolition on Sunday evening, yet Fox Footy's specialists worry there's still issues for trainer Chris Fagan.Despite a magnificent start where the Lions leapt out to a 60-0 top, surrendering Carlton to a 50-year footy low, Brisbane at that point went more than 30 minutes without a goal.And they managed to butcher a number of opportunities when the warmth originated from an increasing Woe outfit." Brisbane, I reckon there's some distressing signs there certainly for Chris Fagan," three-time premiership Leopard Jack Riewoldt pointed out." They ought to possess done a number on Carlton tonight. They must possess put that nail in the casket early in the 2nd one-half." Sadly, they permit all of them back in. They failed to win tough." The activity was over just after part opportunity." AFL terrific Garry Lyon conceded, highlighting the simple fact they won by merely 28 aspects - even with the early 60-0 scoreline.From that aspect in the 2nd phrase, Brisbane were actually outscored 71-39. Lions BLITZ Woe in Removal Final|02:39" 2nd one-half has actually been a concern by means of the training program of the year. A bit of failing," Lyon said.Lions terrific Jonathan Brown mentioned he is afraid of the problem is actually mental for the youthful Lions, as miscalculation and an incapability to sustain their very first one-half tension remains to roll on." I experience as if it is actually not a health and fitness point, certainly not an energy thing. I presume it is actually a little bit of a mental switch off," he claimed." It resides in their head." They kicked properly very early in the activity (versus Carlton), however after half opportunity they were actually common." I presume when resistance acquires a run on, there's a feeling of panic. Some stress and anxiety in there. There is actually some scars, no doubt concerning that." They haven't managed to cope with the stress in those vital instants with those crucial boots-- that's mosting likely to be actually the challenge following full week." They overlook a ton of easy gos." I have actually viewed them closely all year-- I am actually a passionate Brisbane Lions promoter. They miss effortless chance ats goal. Establish chances or even on the run." Versus cry, Logan Morris reached the blog post from directly in front while the edge butchered one more possibility when they possessed an overlap inside fifty and also stopped working to strike a target.Riewoldt defined the reliability concerns because of "reverse pressure". They rank 15th in the AFL for accuracy this year, in front of merely West Coast, Richmond and also Port Adelaide.In their last 4 matches, Brisbane have actually gone 44.64 on the scoreboard, along with goalkicking costing all of them a top-four place when they shed 8.16 to GWS' 13.4 in Sphere 22. They also shed winnable video games against Carlton in Position Sphere (12.13 to 13.8), Collingwood in Sphere 3 (10.12 to 14.8) as well as Geelong in Around 6 (4.13 to 9.9) due to their error." What have our experts reached drop?"|04:23' WE'VE GOT TO IMPROVEMENT THAT RULE': IS AFL HONOR phone call UNFAIR?Players as well as analysts claim it's opportunity for the AFL to listen closely to the followers and also alter the qualification standards encompassing the Score and Objective of the Year awards.First it was Jeremy Cameron's wonderful end, put near to the limit collection on Thursday evening, as he received the Pussy-cats off to an aspiration start at the Adelaide Oval. On Sunday evening it was actually Swans super star Isaac Heeney, who defied gravity to take some of the everlasting terrific grabs. Awful component-- neither are going to be actually entitled for the prominent awards.As it stands up, merely instants in the home as well as away period are taken into consideration for the awards, which are presented on Brownlow Medal night before the splendid ultimate. But following finding 2 of the period's most eye-catching seconds, there is actually been plenty of calls for the AFL to change its own rules. "Our team've come to alter that policy, Jeremy Cameron kicked objective of the year in finals and after that Isaac Heeney's taken mark of the year," Swans tiny onward Tom Papley informed 3AW post-match. Jezza opens up finals series with astonishment!|00:35 Channel 9's Damian Barrett additionally participated in the carolers of pros asking for improvement, mentioning he believed Heeney's hanger was actually the best mark of the year. "That to me is mark of the year yet unfortunately it will not be consisted of in the factors," he lamented on the Sunday Footy Show.Former Tiger and Bulldog Nathan Brown remained in agreeance." I assume it ought to be actually, you return to 1997, Aussie Jones kicked the goal of the year in the grand final, individuals mention the other teams don't receive a chance, I mean there is actually a couple of chances," he said.Jones kicked an amazing running target in the '97 huge last, while former Roo Aaron Edwards took a substantial mark versus Hawthorn in the 2007 semi-final that has actually been "shed in background" given its ineligibility for the award.Former AFL player Josh Jenkins was also amongst those that spoke up concerning their ridicule, taking to X to claim: "Objective of the year right there certainly ... wait they have actually finalized elections." As a football society, gamers that stand on the most significant phase of all are actually praised as well as discover their place in footy mythology, so why are the Score of the Year and also Objective of the Year honors uninformed of that?When you consider the very best players to play the game, those who have tried results in September are actually consistently among the first players that concern mind.Think Michael Voss, Luke Hodge and Joel Selwood. Premiership leaders who are kept in the greatest regard by all. Players are actually determined by their efficiencies in finals." Leo Barry you star" was actually implanted in past history when the Swans gun floated all over the pack to get that famous sign. Richmond captain Trent Cotchin's tradition was glued when he took his edge back to the paradise. There is actually no guarantee that Heeney's wall mount will one-up Jamie Elliott's ANZAC Day unique, or that Cameron's insane surface will take over that of Nick Daicos or even Harley Reid's goals, but they need to a minimum of be challengers.