.Collingwood's big 2023 off-season move for ex-Fremantle onward Lachie Schultz has happened under fire, with the premiers gazing down the really true scenario of providing a top-10 pick.The Magpies depended their 2024 fortunes when they traded away select 34 plus their future first-round selection for Schultz in the most recent exchange period.With a lot of the AFL world assuming the Magpies to require the leading four once again, this trade valued Schultz at approximately pick 8, depending on to the AFL Draft Value Index - a higher price yet one they agreed to spend, if they were actually turning over one thing like selection 16. See Hawthorn v Collingwood SAT 4:35 PM AEST|LIVE & special to Fox Footy, offered on Kayo. New to Kayo? Beginning your totally free test today > Round 19WHAT'S GAMING REALLY PRICING YOU? Set a deposit limit.But Collingwood currently sits 12th on the step ladder and also, along with inadequate type and a challenging staying draw, can reasonably end up in all-time low six.As it stands they are going to hand Fremantle the No. 7 selection, along with the total trade then valuing Schultz as around select 4, depending on to the AFL Allotment Value Index.Current Lachie Schultz trade detailsCOLLINGWOOD obtains Lachie SchultzFREMANTLE gets Choose 7 (2024) and also Choose 34 (2023 )Decide on 34 was actually on-traded to Richmond and afterwards West Shoreline, used by the Eagles on Clay-based HallCraig McRae, Elder Train of the Magpies consults with Lachie Schultz of the Magpies at region opportunity during the 2024 AFL Cycle 12 suit between the Collingwood Magpies and also the Adelaide Crows at The Melbourne Cricket Ground on May 31, 2024 in Melbourne, Australia. (Photo through Dylan Burns/AFL Photos through Getty Images) Source: Getty Images" The field that they produced to receive Lachie Schultz in, which I sustained back then, I thought this was actually gon na be an excellent employ," Kane Cornes stated on 9's Footy Classified." Yet you consider it six months down the keep track of, you go, effectively this has been a catastrophe really. And also they let Ginnivan go." Ginnivan's willing to switch 22 by the end of the year, Schultz is gon na be actually 27, as well as Ginnivan is making significantly greater impact in pretty much every stat ... he is actually been actually a far more impactful player." Cornes is actually not quite proper on the players' 2024 creation, with Schultz in advance on the all-inclusive AFL Gamer Scores measurement and also creating more objectives, handles as well as pressure functions per game.LACHIE SCHULTZ vs JACK GINNIVAN in 2024 (Standards) Fingertips: Schultz 11.3, Ginnivan 16Marks inside fifty: Schultz 1.5, Ginnivan 1.3 Objectives: Schultz 1.3, Ginnivan 1.1 Credit rating aids: Schultz 0.5, Ginnivan 1.1 Rating participations: Schultz 4.8, Ginnivan 5.5 Tackles: Schultz 3.87, Ginnivan 2.53 Stress acts: Schultz 18.1, Ginnivan 15.5 AFL Player Ratings: Schultz 6.85, Ginnivan 5.98 Having said that the impacts of the pair are actually very much comparable, while the price paid to obtain Schultz and return for Ginnivan are not.Ginnivan was traded to Hawthorn in a multi-pick swap, with Collingwood receiving pick 33 plus the Hawks' 2024 2nd as well as third-round choices, while the Hawks acquired Ginnivan, choose 39 and also the Magpies' 2024 second and fourth-round picks.Given the Hawks were anticipated to complete below the Magpies, the potential choice swaps were actually recognized as a succeed for Collingwood, but they may possess actually devalued those assortments creating the profession just about a comprehensive wash.It is certainly no place close to the top-10 choice return Fremantle is likely to acquire for Schultz." What has actually happened to our terrific activity!"|03:35" One of the most involving factor is you handed out Select 7 as it sits today. That's what our company've come to take place, and also they have actually got a challenging draw plus all of that," Cornes said." Therefore you have actually traded your future first for a gamer that is actually primarily delivering what you possessed with one more player, that you gave away for pretty much absolutely nothing, and you've also provided that great selection inside the best 10 as it sits - which they seriously need to have." The Magpies can desperately make use of that option along with an outdated checklist as well as a shortage of skill gotten using the national allotment in current years.While Nick Daicos is a superstar, and also the similarity Isaac Quaynor (pick thirteen) and Beau McCreery (choose 44) were actually terrific pick-ups, Craig McRae's edge has actually or else battled at the allotment along with perhaps merely four smash hits in five years.From the 2021-23 allotments only Harvey Harrison has actually played double-digit games, while 2018 as well as 2019 provided nothing at all beyond Quaynor.In the 2020 draft, where the Pies had 4 picks in the leading 30 as well as 6 in the leading 44, only McCreery and also the since-traded Ollie Henry are actually crystal clear best-23 players.The selections of John Royalty and Ash Johnson in the mid-season draft, plus pre-season extra pick-up Oleg Markov, have been actually required offered the nationwide allotment overlooks.